20 August 2010

A Thinking Machine -metaphors for mind

A big chunk of late 20th century thinking about thinking/brains/minds was dominated by computational metaphors, and my informal recollection would say that this accelerated in the 80s as people increasingly had their own computers at home. So I was very interest to see this article about language which draws attention to the way that computational metaphor has influenced and been used in thinking about language: A Thinking Machine: On metaphors for mind | Child's Play here's how it works: "the mind is like a spreadsheet: a prefabricated architecture that follows a strict, rule-based program, that rigidly structures its inputs and outputs in just such a way."
So what's the alternative? Well, there have been some more serious attempts to dethrone this metaphor:
By this suggestion, when we hear or read language, the computational principles of this innate grammar conduct a series of logical operations, which parse the incoming stream according to its component parts, and so yield understanding.
But what if this is simply the wrong metaphor?

What if – say – language is more like a search engine? ....
A search engine is a probabilistic, predictive learning machine. Unlike spreadsheets, search engines do not engage with their input in a determinate, preprogrammed manner. Instead of rigidly structuring incoming information according to some prefabricated set of rules, they discover structure within information. ...
This metaphor gives rise to a fundamentally different view of language: one in which language acquisition relies on relatively simple – yet powerful – learning mechanisms, and in which language comprehension and production is fundamentally predictive, rather than determinate.

No comments:

Review: It happened in Hell

 It seemed to me that this book set out to do two main things. One was to demonstrate that so many of our notions of what goes under the lab...