Skip to main content

We have to negotiate a new "masculinity"

Now before anything else, I in tandem with this article referred to in the title-link, would strongly recognise the way that women are still bedevilled by glass ceilings and being disproportionately involved with childcare and domestic labour and being sexually victimised and exploited.

That said, the writing is on the wall for once-unquestioned definitions of masculinity in terms of how we understand it in wider cultural milieus. And this article tries to point up some of the challenge.
The general impression of millions of men as essentially confused, hidebound creatures, in search of certainties that the modern world has left behind, adds up. This is hardly new – quite rightly, Rosin goes back to Susan Faludi's trailblazing 1999 book Stiffed. But in the last 15 years or so, the problem seems to have got even worse, and it seems incontestably true that millions of men have "lost the architecture of manliness but … not replaced it with any new ones".The end of men? Cardboard man is dead. Now let's redefine masculinity | John Harris
 Unfortunately we've not got much of a handle on alternative narratives except the for the clearly unhelpful Peter Pan reactions.
if you're the average halfway educated white male, what have you got to hang on to, besides what looks like textbook overcompensation? An affected interest in that great theatre of tissue-thin masculinity, football? Some vague, porn-informed idea that you can transplant the comical power relations glimpsed online into the bedroom, and demonstrate who's boss? Or just my own generation's large-scale retreat into a kind of blank infantilism, whereby even grownup dads wear saggy shorts they bought in Fat Face, fidget with their phones, and talk loudly about how much they had to drink last night? Men, writes Rosin, "could move more quickly into new roles open to them … nurse, teacher, full-time father." They could, but they usually don't.
I'd want to bring to the discussion the observation that a 'customer-service culture' requires a fuller ability with attributes traditionally associated with traditional definitions of femininity: empathy, attention to the needs of others and similar. Now note that I use words like 'associated' and 'traditional definitions'. There are very few genuine differences between men and women that are hard-and-fast. There are statistical likelihoods, but even these may be more due to culture than biochemical hard-wiring. (For more see Delusions of Gender). Men are quite capable of learning to do all this stuff -as many demonstrate- even where they have shown little interest or apparent aptitude before. The only thing stopping them/us is laddishness and similar dysadaptations of cultural repertoire.

So the real issue is about us negotiating a new cultural settlement. And this can only really happen by men thinking about this together and with women, trying things out and not accepting sexist responses.

I'm wondering what Christian men have to bring to the table. In some cases a restatement of the attitudes that are now a problem: certain traditional 'readings' of scripture or complementarianism, it seems to me, are simply attempting to fix an unsustainable and ulitimately unjust and personhood-diminishing set of gender stereotypes. at best this may help some men (and perhaps some women) to hold on until something new appears.

Let me say what I think that Christian men might be bringing to the big cultural negotiation, at our best. We follow someone who taught that being great is about serving others (including women and children), who showed leadership in promoting good for those around him and in setting them free to be fuller people with more expansive opportunities. It seems to me that however we define (cultural) masculinity, it has to work within a set of parameters which  embed service and the common good, the welfare of others. In fact, I can't see how that differs from femininity. This is counter cultural in terms of old definitions. But we have to question traditional masculinities which would problematise turning the other cheek or walking an extra mile as being 'unmanly'.

The real difficulty with masculinity is that there is no universally accepted/approved version any longer, leaving some men in crisis, trying to live out of models which seem ridiculous to many and which tend to lead to diminishing outcomes and failure in life strategies. Paradoxically, we have to ask; are we 'man enough' to change and to do the right thing. Are we 'man enough' to reject laddishness, yobbishness and emotional-stuntedness? We have to be 'man enough' to be be comfortable in our own gendered skins and not to be fazed by the fact that many times who we are does not fit the stereotypes. We have to be 'man enough' to affirm others who are unstereotypical in their self-presentation of masculinity.

Ironically, too, I suspect that part of helping us to negotiate through into a new world of male and female, could be learning from and with gay and transgender people. They are potentially part of the solution and a God-given gift to us all to help us understand culture, nature and nurture in gender and relationships.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Foundation, Empire -and the mission of the church

 I've been watching the TV series 'Foundation'. I read the books about 50 years ago (I know!) but scarcely now remember anything but an outline and some character names. A lot has happened in my life since I read the series and now watch it adapted to television. For one thing, I committed my ways to Christ and have a role which involves official ministry in the church's mission. In the intervening years, a constant companion for me has been concern for ecology, for creation. Latterly this has become a more urgent concern and I have realised that we have collectively run out of time. We are living on borrowed time. In fact, some of us, globally speaking, are not even living on borrowed time. All through my adult life I have unconsciously (I now realise) assumed that we would have time, that there was time to persuade and to change and to head off the worst. That assumption, that naive hope, has now been stripped from me. The situation of living on borrowed time  needs t

Pray ceaselessly, but how?

I've just had an article published on emergingchurch.info. It's an adaptation of some of my book, but I thought I'd share it and give you a taster... ... ask ourselves whether there is a way of understanding the command to pray ceaselessly in a way that doesn't conflict with loving our neighbour. Paul may have meant his readers to pray as much as they could, whenever they could. However that would be to read a meaning into the text based, perhaps on a sense of realism faced with an understanding of prayer that involves giving God full and exclusive attention. We don't have to be bound by that interpretation. I'm going to suggest a deeper fulfilment of the exhortation. One that makes contact with Paul's command to his Roman readers to offer their bodies as living sacrifices to God (Romans 12.1-2). Perhaps Paul was suggesting making life into prayer rather than making prayer into a life emergingchurch.info > reflection > andii bowsher : Filed in: prayer

The Lords Prayer in Aramaic

I came across this a year or two back and was quite concerned that it was being purveyed as a translation when it quite clearly is not. Now my Hebrew is not extensive but enough that when combined with training in linguistics and biblical interpretation I can tell when a 'midrash' is being offered. [PS inserted here. Since I wrote this originally and noting that this post gets a lot of hits, I have continued to research and would like to encourage readers to visit more recent posts here and here and I tend to add thinngs from time to time to a Squidoo Lens dedicated to the topic of Aramaic Lord's prayer] Anyway, see for yourself the discrepancy between the quantity in the original and the English (as far as I can tell, the orthography is vaguely german, so 'j' is a 'y' sound etc.) The Prayer To Our Father (in the original Aramaic) Abwun "Oh Thou, from whom the breath of life comes, d'bwaschmaja who fills all realms of sound, light and vibration.