06 March 2014

Genesis and the Rise of Civilization -a review

I have had to be careful how many books I pick up for review for Speakeasy -I've got a reading list to work through for various ongoing writing projects of my own. However, when I sow this being offered for review*, I knew I had to have a look at it. Genesis and the Rise of Civilization by J. Snodgrass:  The Goodreads review is short but captures what drew me in.
 Snodgrass Integrates Studies of World Mythologies, Ancient Near Eastern Tribes and Empires, Archaeology and Rabbinic Stories to Read Genesis as a Parable about the Agricultural Revolution, and God's Counter-Revolution.
You see I'm finding myself fascinated by all of those things, so having them in one book ... well, several birthdays came at once. And the Goodreads blurb is right. I've enjoyed the insights brought to bear on specific stories or sections of stories by archaeological anthropology: these have been very insightful. Not always will they be congenial to a certain kind of literalism that can't countenance history or even pre-history beyond 6,000 years ago, or those who can only conceive that truth can be told by straight-forward historiography and are suspicious of the truth that can be told by parable, legend and mythical storytelling. What Snodgrass does is enable us to appreciate the truths that these kinds of language can tell.

As I've read this, it has become more evident to me that I'm going to be returning to it when I'm reflecting on the early chapters of Genesis and due to preach about them.

one of the themes that emerges clearly from this reading based upon prehistory reconstructed from archaeology and anthropology, is the conflict between pastoralists and agriculturalists in which the latter emerged the victors.  The interesting thing it makes clear is the way that, contrary to the myths and legends of most other civilisations of the shift from hunter-gatherer to settled agriculture, the Bible we have tends to exhibit sympathy for the pastoralists and to sound out the warnings about the downsides of agriculturally based ways of life.

The bigger picture of cultural difference and change is interspersed with little titbits of information which made me stop and think more. For example, what if it is right that Abram's wife Sarai's name reflects a background in her being an intentionally childless (ex)-priestess of the Moon-goddess cult. Could she and Abram have been fleeing a situation -eloping together for religious convictions?

The author is a teacher in church settings, and occasionally that background shows through in the writing in asides, puns and witticisms. I enjoyed these but i expect some readers might find them less scholarly and others that there aren't enough of them to properly lighten a scholarly book.

It's not a short book -though half of it is index etc.  There's something of interest on every page so reading it is not a hard job.

*Disclosure of Material Connection: I received this book free from the  publisher through the Speakeasy blogging book review network. I was not required to write a positive review. The opinions I have expressed are my own. I am disclosing this in accordance with the Federal Trade Commission’s 16 CFR,Part 255 -even though I am British, residing in Britain.

2 comments:

Matt Stone said...

Thanks for the heads up Andii. I've downloaded a Kindle preview to check it out further.

Andii said...

There's a couple of things in it I struggle with, but they're worth living with and thinking about further for a lot of helpfully provocative material. I found it hard to be convinced about pitting El and YHWH against one another in the Jacob@Jabbok story, for example ...

A review: One With The Father

I'm a bit of a fan of medieval mysteries especially where there are monastic and religious dimensions to them. That's what drew me t...