Skip to main content

Gender Identity; justice, equality and the interim

I just came across this in an article entitled Jordan Peterson, Identity Politics, and the Church – Covenant:
"Gender is constructed, but an individual who desires gender re-assignment surgery is to be unarguably considered a man trapped in a woman’s body (or vice versa). The fact that both of these cannot logically be true, simultaneously, is just ignored (or rationalized away with another appalling post-modern claim: that logic itself — along with the techniques of science — is merely part of the oppressive patriarchal system.)"

I'm interested in it because it seems a reactionary response from someone who is usually intellectually rigourous but it is a question that presupposes an inadequate answer and implies that we should therefore stop doing this. I think it is missing a 'tactical' response and one which recognises that in such complex contestations in society we have to recognise that we are always in media res -in the midst of things. And that being 'in-between' sometimes requires different and temporary responses than would occur at the end of a process of deliberation when all the relevant facts and perspectives appear to be known, understood and categorised.

While I recognise the logical impasse, I think this misses the point. The point is that at this moment in our cultural history, we appear to be in the middle of some awakenings of understanding about psychology, identity, personal formation and so on. We are also not yet well informed about genes and epigenetic influences in relation to gender identity and sexuality.

This means we are in a period of social and cultural apprehension (in both the sense of apprehending something and worrying about it) where understandings are not evenly distributed across our culture and indeed are contested and under negotiation.

So this does not mean I'm claiming that logic is out when I affirm both that gender is constructed and that I take the experience of trans people seriously in terms of how they relate to their physical 'birth' gender (and that's not including those where that is more of a grey area, about which more might be said).

My 'tactical' response is first to note that while physical 'birth' gender does make some difference: average (note: not absolute) muscle strength and perhaps, again on average, some tasks relating to spatial awareness, it is not absolute differences because there are huge overlaps and across a range of skills and dispositions both men and women appear to be equally competent and able given unhampered initial conditions. There is important research emerging with psychological grounding which seems to be indicating that many so-called innate gender differences are very likely to be to do with the previously unnoticed priming for difference and expectation that goes on at very, very early stages of an infant's life. And until we can unpick the hormonal from the priming from the stereotyping and the social ... but it looks likely that men and women are mostly differentiated by social constructions about roles and abilities which we imbibe at early ages on account of the main innate human early trait being to take in information voraciously and begin to use it to guide behaviour and attitudes using mimetic strategies cued by significant others around us. So while we can begin to recognise that hugely and preponderantly gender is a social construction, we have to come at that with a weight of cultural history and personal development which makes it feel like gender roles are almost physically/genetically innate.

This means, I think, that transgender identification has to work with the cultural gender 'memes' that our societies overwhelmingly re/present in huge swathes of culture. It will take a lot of time and effort as societies to work out what is going on and how.
In the mean time we have people suffering gender dysphoria.
Loving our neighbour means we should be compassionately seeking to help them.
So, for the time being, 'tactically', we can only take the felt sense of being mis-gendered with utmost seriousness. Maybe, one day, we'll have more to bring to understanding the conditions. But for today we have to work at both projects simultaneously and with compassion and earnestness for those who are caught between gender, culture and social respect.

The logical difficulty that Jordan Peterson mentions is actually one that rests on certain understandings of gender which we are discovering may not be serving us well in various ways -either in truthfulness or in psycho-social health. The logical impasse may, actually, start to burn away once we understand better and more the issues mentioned above.
So, in the meantime, we treat the persons in front of us with utmost seriousness and do the best we can.

Transgendered people may be able, even, to help us to better understand culture and psychology around gender in such a way as to free all of us from unhelpful gender-related 'templates' (the line 'big boys don't cry' haunts me from a 10cc song [I'm not in Love] -as a false and vastly unhelpful gender norm, for example. And to be fair, I think the song was questioning the norm).


See also my posts here and here.
'via Blog this'

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Foundation, Empire -and the mission of the church

 I've been watching the TV series 'Foundation'. I read the books about 50 years ago (I know!) but scarcely now remember anything but an outline and some character names. A lot has happened in my life since I read the series and now watch it adapted to television. For one thing, I committed my ways to Christ and have a role which involves official ministry in the church's mission. In the intervening years, a constant companion for me has been concern for ecology, for creation. Latterly this has become a more urgent concern and I have realised that we have collectively run out of time. We are living on borrowed time. In fact, some of us, globally speaking, are not even living on borrowed time. All through my adult life I have unconsciously (I now realise) assumed that we would have time, that there was time to persuade and to change and to head off the worst. That assumption, that naive hope, has now been stripped from me. The situation of living on borrowed time  needs t

Pray ceaselessly, but how?

I've just had an article published on emergingchurch.info. It's an adaptation of some of my book, but I thought I'd share it and give you a taster... ... ask ourselves whether there is a way of understanding the command to pray ceaselessly in a way that doesn't conflict with loving our neighbour. Paul may have meant his readers to pray as much as they could, whenever they could. However that would be to read a meaning into the text based, perhaps on a sense of realism faced with an understanding of prayer that involves giving God full and exclusive attention. We don't have to be bound by that interpretation. I'm going to suggest a deeper fulfilment of the exhortation. One that makes contact with Paul's command to his Roman readers to offer their bodies as living sacrifices to God (Romans 12.1-2). Perhaps Paul was suggesting making life into prayer rather than making prayer into a life emergingchurch.info > reflection > andii bowsher : Filed in: prayer

The Lords Prayer in Aramaic

I came across this a year or two back and was quite concerned that it was being purveyed as a translation when it quite clearly is not. Now my Hebrew is not extensive but enough that when combined with training in linguistics and biblical interpretation I can tell when a 'midrash' is being offered. [PS inserted here. Since I wrote this originally and noting that this post gets a lot of hits, I have continued to research and would like to encourage readers to visit more recent posts here and here and I tend to add thinngs from time to time to a Squidoo Lens dedicated to the topic of Aramaic Lord's prayer] Anyway, see for yourself the discrepancy between the quantity in the original and the English (as far as I can tell, the orthography is vaguely german, so 'j' is a 'y' sound etc.) The Prayer To Our Father (in the original Aramaic) Abwun "Oh Thou, from whom the breath of life comes, d'bwaschmaja who fills all realms of sound, light and vibration.